please note: i just read/skimmed/barfed on every single entry to
qaf_anon. most of them i barfed on. out of the entire list of like three million stories, there were approximately (exactly) six that i liked and did not find painfully pretentious or badly-written or just plain retardedly stupid, ok! they are the following:
codai guess i should admit that i did not read this all the way through. but what i read, i liked! i no longer have the undying love for brian and justin that is required for plodding through very long stories. however, i very much enjoyed the opening, with hunter & co. betting on how long brian will last in pittsburgh, and i also liked the very end where brian and justin fell in love again. i think that is really enough, don't you?
my guess for who wrote it: fuck if i know!
darksylvia, maybe, or
luceononuro. or
nightsister! truly, anything is possible.
the luckiest guy in new york citythis story is very cute, and i love very much that it includes the phrase "your cat lady neighbor." also, it is clearly written by someone who really loves new york, and justin loves people who love new york. please go read it; you will not be sorry, and you might learn something about how to write second person and not appear to be challenged in the fundamentals of the english language.
my guess for who wrote it:
twistinside82, because she loves the new yorks a lot!!
thin iceplease, let there be no question about it: this story is a
buffy the vampire slayer crossover. despite this intial shortcoming, or at least my perception that it would be a shortcoming, i totally loved it. it is filled with clever, witty little gems and tops off with an ethan gold/scott hope joke. who can beat that?
my guess for who wrote it: if it's not
valerie_z, i'll eat debbie's underpants.
a wave unfurledthere is a lot of sexual relations here, and that is something that i like very much. the sexual relations, i mean. there are also other things that i like, but i cannot explain. i just liked it!
my guess for who wrote it:
negativeerin? i'm pretty sure, but you don't have to take my word for it!!
unluckyWAH. THIS STORY WAS SO SAD BUT I LOVED IT ANYWAY. it is about carnivals and "party naked" t-shirts and lottery tickets, but still it was very sad!!! also it reminded me of
valerie_z's story "lucky," which was about monkey butlers, and that just makes the entire thing that much better. but rest assured, author of this story, i loved it on its own too!
my guess for who wrote it:
severina2001, because it is short and sweet.
tally marksfor the record: this was my favorite, by far. by far!!! i mean, a contest where brian and justin try to make more people fall in love with them? perfect. it was definitely the best idea out of the entries, including the one where justin got hit by a meteor and the one where the devil pretended justin had AIDS. it was also a better idea than the one where... well, all those other ones. the bottom line: I LOVE THIS STORY. LOVE LOVE LOVE.
my guess for who wrote it: i would bet my entire life that this story is by
ragingpixie, and i swear that is an honest-to-goodness guess and she did not tell me this!!!!
EDIT: here and here, you can read about why i didn't like any of those other stories very much.